Saturday, February 04, 2006

A Million Little 'It Doesn't Matter's

A few weeks ago, thesmokinggun.com discovered that James Frey, the author of the book "A Million Little Pieces" fabricated much of his supposed memoir about recovering from a drug addiction. Oprah initially supported Frey, saying that he wrote a very good book, then she turned 180 and gave the guy a public lashing on her TV show. Frey simply took all that Oprah had like a frightened puppy.

The circumstances surrounding the book's publishing was that Frey apparently tried to sell the book to the publisher as a fictional novel, but the publisher wanted Frey to claim it was a memoir so that it would sell better. This could have worked until Oprah made it part of her book club which immediately sent it to national prominence and ultimately made skeptical people question Frey's claims.

This revelation brought about the question of whether it mattered that the book was mostly false, since part of its impact was that this guy went through such a horrific ordeal in order to clean up his life. I don't think it really does. My feeling is that the guy wrote an excellent book that affected a lot of people. I certainly think there should be some reprecussion for Frey and his publisher for marketing the book on false premises, but I definitely think Oprah went too far with how she abused him on her show. To her defense, this guy embarrassed her and will make people unfairly skeptical of future books she puts on her list. But the guy has been called out on the carpet for weeks and Oprah tries to make herself feel better by bombarding him with her righteous indignation. I think Oprah does a lot of good, especially with the book club, but I have never liked how judgemental she is with some of her guests.

I think James Frey should have taken his lumps to an extent, but once people started acting like he's some sort of monster, he should have fired back that he exaggerated reality to make his authentic message of redemption more compelling, he's sorry, he wishes he had been more forthcoming. But in the end, he wrote a very good book that probably changed a lot of people's lives. The lie got the readers into the book, but the fact that it wasn't true in his case shouldn't detract that this is what addiction and recovery can be like and that it should be a cautionary tale to people who think that they can dabble in drugs and not be harmed.

Frey deserved most of the criticism he got, but he's not a rapist or a murderer, so he shouldn't be vilified like one.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home